| Year | School | State |
|---|---|---|
| 1992 | Grand Island Central Catholic | Nebraska |
| 1992 | Wheaton St Francis | Illinois |
| 1992 | Buffalo City Honors | New York |
| 1993 | Grand Island Central Catholic | Nebraska |
| 1993 | Hermann | Missouri |
| 1994 | Grand Island Central Catholic | Nebraska |
| 1996 | Breese Central | Illinois |
| 1997 | Hermann | Missouri |
| 1998 | St Joseph's Academy | Missouri |
| 1999 | Normal University | Illinois |
| 2000 | Hermann | Missouri |
| 2000 | Normal University | Illinois |
| 2001 | Hermann | Missouri |
| 2002 | Hermann | Missouri |
| 2004 | Indianapolis Bishop Chatard | Indiana |
| 2004 | Lutheran H. S. of St Charles Co. | Missouri |
| 2005 | Breese Central | Illinois |
| 2006 | Wheaton St Francis | Illinois |
| 2006 | Hartsburg-Emden | Illinois |
| 2006 | Hermann | Missouri |
| 2007 | Breese Central | Illinois |
| 2008 | Hermann | Missouri |
| 2010 | Jonesboro Valley View | Arkansas |
| 2010 | Hermann | Missouri |